Carriyo vs AfterShip
Discover what's the best option between Carriyo and ShipStation for your business.
100+
out-of-the-box delivery services for your business including Same Day, Next Day, Express and Cross-border delivery.
Comparing AfterShip and Carriyo
When it comes to choosing a shipping management platform, selecting the right solution depends on your business needs. Carriyo and AfterShip are two well-known solutions, each with distinct strengths. In this detailed comparison, we break down their capabilities, features, and key differences to help you make an informed decision.
 |  | |
|---|---|---|
Branded Tracking Pages | Basic tracking pages with limited branding options (Shopify-only for advanced customization). | Fully customizable tracking pages that reflect your brand’s identity. |
Delivery Notifications | Automated email and SMS notifications with standard templates. | Personalized SMS, email, and WhatsApp notifications with tailored messaging. |
Customer Engagement | Focuses on delivery updates without advanced engagement features. | Tools for upselling, cross-selling, and gathering feedback during delivery. |
Returns Management | Advanced self-service returns portal, but requires a separate subscription. | Integrated returns functionality within the same platform. |
Sustainability | Carbon footprint reduction tool for eco-friendly businesses. | No dedicated sustainability tool. |
Pricing | Modular pricing—separate subscriptions for tracking, shipping, returns, etc. | Clear, all-in-one pricing with no hidden costs. |
Ease of Use | Feature-rich but fragmented across multiple platforms and subscriptions. | Intuitive interface with everything in one platform. |
| | |
|---|---|---|
Branded Tracking Pages | Basic tracking pages with limited branding options (Shopify-only for advanced customization). | Fully customizable tracking pages that reflect your brand’s identity. |
Delivery Notifications | Automated email and SMS notifications with standard templates. | Personalized SMS, email, and WhatsApp notifications with tailored messaging. |
Customer Engagement | Focuses on delivery updates without advanced engagement features. | Tools for upselling, cross-selling, and gathering feedback during delivery. |
Returns Management | Advanced self-service returns portal, but requires a separate subscription. | Integrated returns functionality within the same platform. |
Sustainability | Carbon footprint reduction tool for eco-friendly businesses. | No dedicated sustainability tool. |
Pricing | Modular pricing—separate subscriptions for tracking, shipping, returns, etc. | Clear, all-in-one pricing with no hidden costs. |
Ease of Use | Feature-rich but fragmented across multiple platforms and subscriptions. | Intuitive interface with everything in one platform. |
Which Shipping Platform is Right for Your Business?
Choosing the right shipping management platform can have a significant impact on your logistics efficiency, customer experience, and overall operational costs. Whether you're looking for advanced automation, seamless multi-carrier integration, or enhanced customer engagement, understanding the core differences between Carriyo and AfterShip will help you make the best decision for your business needs.
Carrier Integration & Automation
Both Carriyo and AfterShip support around 100 carrier integrations, providing businesses with flexibility in their shipping operations. However, Carriyo offers more advanced automation capabilities when it comes to carrier selection. With Carriyo, businesses can define precise rules to automatically assign specific carriers based on factors such as destination, shipping cost, delivery time, or product type. This allows for greater control over logistics and ensures the most optimized shipping option for each order.
AfterShip also includes automated carrier selection, but its functionality is less granular. Businesses can choose between the fastest or cheapest carrier, but they cannot specify an exact carrier based on multiple conditions. This makes AfterShip a viable solution for general optimization but less suitable for businesses that require a more strategic and customized carrier allocation system.
Branded Tracking and Customization
While both platforms offer branded tracking pages, Carriyo takes customization to the next level, ensuring that every touchpoint reflects your brand’s identity.
Carriyo: Fully customizable tracking pages allow you to incorporate your brand’s logos, colors, and personalized messaging. This level of customization helps create a cohesive brand experience that delights customers and builds loyalty. Carriyo also offers tools for upselling, cross-selling, and collecting feedback during the delivery process, turning the post-purchase journey into an opportunity for engagement.- AfterShip: Offers basic branded tracking pages, but the customization options are limited compared to Carriyo. Importantly, AfterShip’s branding customization is delivered through a Shopify app, which means it’s only available to Shopify users. If you’re using a different e-commerce platform (like WooCommerce, Magento, or a custom solution), you won’t have access to these branding features.
For businesses that don’t use Shopify, this limitation can be a significant drawback. Carriyo, on the other hand, provides platform-agnostic branding customization, ensuring that all businesses—regardless of their e-commerce platform—can deliver a premium branded experience.
Sustainability Features
AfterShip has an edge when it comes to sustainability, offering a carbon footprint reduction tool that helps businesses track and offset their environmental impact. This feature, often referred to as the “green” initiative, is a great addition for businesses looking to align with eco-friendly practices.
- AfterShip: Provides tools to measure and reduce carbon emissions, appealing to environmentally conscious brands.
- Carriyo: While Carriyo does not currently offer a dedicated sustainability tool, its focus on streamlining operations and reducing inefficiencies indirectly contributes to a smaller environmental footprint.
If sustainability is a top priority for your business, AfterShip’s carbon footprint tool may be a deciding factor.
Pricing
Pricing is where the two platforms differ significantly, and it’s an important factor to consider when choosing a solution.
- Carriyo: Offers clear, all-in-one pricing with no hidden costs. Everything—tracking, notifications, returns, and analytics—is included in one subscription. This transparency makes it easier to budget and scale your operations without worrying about unexpected fees.
- AfterShip: Operates on a modular pricing model, requiring separate subscriptions for tracking, shipping, returns, and more. This can lead to higher costs and operational complexity, as businesses need to manage multiple subscriptions and platforms. For example, if you want to use AfterShip for both tracking and returns, you’ll need to purchase two separate subscriptions and switch between different platforms to manage them.
Carriyo’s all-in-one pricing model simplifies the process and ensures that you have everything you need in a single platform, making it a more cost-effective and user-friendly choice.
You can also click on the button down below to access our pricing page, and take a look at our new startup discount !
Carrier Integration & Automation
Both Carriyo and AfterShip support around 100 carrier integrations, providing businesses with flexibility in their shipping operations. However, Carriyo offers more advanced automation capabilities when it comes to carrier selection. With Carriyo, businesses can define precise rules to automatically assign specific carriers based on factors such as destination, shipping cost, delivery time, or product type. This allows for greater control over logistics and ensures the most optimized shipping option for each order.
AfterShip also includes automated carrier selection, but its functionality is less granular. Businesses can choose between the fastest or cheapest carrier, but they cannot specify an exact carrier based on multiple conditions. This makes AfterShip a viable solution for general optimization but less suitable for businesses that require a more strategic and customized carrier allocation system.
Branded Tracking and Customization
While both platforms offer branded tracking pages, Carriyo takes customization to the next level, ensuring that every touchpoint reflects your brand’s identity.
- Carriyo: Fully customizable tracking pages allow you to incorporate your brand’s logos, colors, and personalized messaging. This level of customization helps create a cohesive brand experience that delights customers and builds loyalty. Carriyo also offers tools for upselling, cross-selling, and collecting feedback during the delivery process, turning the post-purchase journey into an opportunity for engagement.
- AfterShip: Offers basic branded tracking pages, but the customization options are limited compared to Carriyo. Importantly, AfterShip’s branding customization is delivered through a Shopify app, which means it’s only available to Shopify users. If you’re using a different e-commerce platform (like WooCommerce, Magento, or a custom solution), you won’t have access to these branding features.
For businesses that don’t use Shopify, this limitation can be a significant drawback. Carriyo, on the other hand, provides platform-agnostic branding customization, ensuring that all businesses—regardless of their e-commerce platform—can deliver a premium branded experience.
Sustainability Features
AfterShip has an edge when it comes to sustainability, offering a carbon footprint reduction tool that helps businesses track and offset their environmental impact. This feature, often referred to as the “green” initiative, is a great addition for businesses looking to align with eco-friendly practices.
- AfterShip: Provides tools to measure and reduce carbon emissions, appealing to environmentally conscious brands.
- Carriyo: While Carriyo does not currently offer a dedicated sustainability tool, its focus on streamlining operations and reducing inefficiencies indirectly contributes to a smaller environmental footprint.
If sustainability is a top priority for your business, AfterShip’s carbon footprint tool may be a deciding factor.
Pricing
Pricing is where the two platforms differ significantly, and it’s an important factor to consider when choosing a solution.
- Carriyo: Offers clear, all-in-one pricing with no hidden costs. Everything—tracking, notifications, returns, and analytics—is included in one subscription. This transparency makes it easier to budget and scale your operations without worrying about unexpected fees.
- AfterShip: Operates on a modular pricing model, requiring separate subscriptions for tracking, shipping, returns, and more. This can lead to higher costs and operational complexity, as businesses need to manage multiple subscriptions and platforms. For example, if you want to use AfterShip for both tracking and returns, you’ll need to purchase two separate subscriptions and switch between different platforms to manage them.
Carriyo’s all-in-one pricing model simplifies the process and ensures that you have everything you need in a single platform, making it a more cost-effective and user-friendly choice.
You can also click on the button down below to access our pricing page, and take a look at our new startup discount !
Conclusion
Both Carriyo and AfterShip are powerful last-mile solutions, but they cater to different needs. Carriyo stands out with its all-in-one platform, transparent pricing, and advanced customization options, making it ideal for businesses that prioritize branding and customer engagement. AfterShip, on the other hand, offers extensive tracking carrier support, developer-friendly tools, and sustainability features, but its modular pricing structure and Shopify-dependent branding customization can complicate operations.
If you’re looking for a streamlined, cost-effective solution that delivers a premium post-purchase experience, Carriyo is the clear choice. However, if your business requires advanced technical integrations, sustainability tools, and you’re a Shopify user, AfterShip may be worth considering.
100%
of our customers get a full return on
investment within the first year
of operation
Automate shipping operations and elevate post-purchase customer experience
We're trusted by
